The U.S. Division of Housing and City Improvement is contemplating taking a primary step to utilizing cryptocurrency, in accordance with a gathering recording and different supplies reviewed by ProPublica and three officers conversant in the matter. Two officers informed ProPublica they imagine the initiative could also be a trial run for using crypto throughout the federal authorities.
The discussions have sparked concern amongst some on the division, particularly in regards to the prospect of paying recipients of main federal grants in cryptocurrency, an uninsured digital asset related to monetary hypothesis, dramatic swings in worth and transnational crime.
The main focus of the discussions up to now has been experimenting with utilizing the underlying know-how that makes crypto doable — the blockchain — to observe HUD grants. Blockchain advocates argue that the know-how is effective by itself for such functions. However the main use of blockchain, in accordance with consultants, is for crypto transactions.
“It’s simply introducing one other unregulated safety into the housing market as if 2008, 2009 didn’t occur,” one HUD staffer stated, referring to the subprime mortgage disaster. “I don’t see any method this can assist something. I see loads of methods this might damage,” stated the official, who, like others on this article, spoke on the situation of anonymity for worry of retribution. The HUD discussions have coated the potential use of a stablecoin, a type of crypto that’s pegged to a different asset to keep away from wild swings in worth, though such swings have occurred prior to now.
The blockchain concept is being pushed, a HUD official informed colleagues, by Irving Dennis. Dennis, the company’s new principal deputy chief monetary officer, is a former accomplice on the world consulting large EY, additionally generally identified by its unique identify, Ernst & Younger. EY itself is concerned within the proposal as effectively: An government of the agency mentioned the thought with HUD officers final month.
What We’re Watching
Throughout Donald Trump’s second presidency, ProPublica will deal with the areas most in want of scrutiny. Listed here are a number of the points our reporters will likely be watching — and the right way to get in contact with them securely.
We’re attempting one thing new. Was it helpful?
The crypto trade has discovered an ally in President Donald Trump, whose administration has tapped industry boosters to guide federal companies, backed off investigations into crypto corporations and created a “strategic Bitcoin reserve.” (Bitcoin plunged $5,000 inside an hour of the information of the reserve’s opening on Thursday.) Trump himself has significant financial interests in crypto. On Friday, the White Home is scheduled to host a “crypto summit” with main figures from the trade.
The proposal at HUD signifies a brand new method that the administration could search to bolster the trade: by incorporating blockchain and presumably cryptocurrency into the routine spending and accounting practices of federal companies. It’s a transfer that may align with the apparent desire of Trump adviser Elon Musk to make use of the blockchain to observe federal spending.
Dennis and HUD spokesperson Kasey Lovett each denied the accounts of their colleagues. “The division has no plans for blockchain or stablecoin,” Lovett stated. “Training isn’t implementation.”
Robert Judson, the EY government concerned within the conversations, confirmed that they occurred. “We as a agency have been having discussions with choose people at that company,” he stated when reached by cellphone. Judson informed ProPublica he would search EY’s approval for a full interview, then didn’t name again.
The White Home, EY and Musk didn’t reply to requests for remark.
HUD officers held at the least two conferences in regards to the blockchain proposal final month. An inventory of attendees to the primary assembly included staffers from the workplaces of the CFO and Neighborhood Planning and Improvement. CPD administers billions of {dollars} in grants that assist low- and moderate-income folks, together with funding to develop reasonably priced housing, run homeless shelters, assist catastrophe restoration, relocate home violence survivors and construct parks, sewers and neighborhood facilities. It was the CFO’s workplace that known as for the assembly, one individual informed ProPublica.
Additionally listed as a gathering attendee was Judson from EY. For years Judson has advocated for the blockchain, a digital ledger of kinds that creates an immutable document of transactions saved throughout a number of computer systems. Boosters of the know-how solid it as a method to lower middlemen similar to banks and bank card corporations out of monetary transactions and make these transactions extra clear and safe. Judson has written that the blockchain might help organizations forestall cash from being siphoned off for unintended functions. “As digital property similar to steady cash or digital currencies take maintain, extra highly effective purposes will emerge for built-in worth change,” he wrote. Dennis, who served as HUD CFO within the first Trump administration, additionally wrote, in a 2021 e-book, that the company ought to use know-how similar to “blockchain, robotics, and next-generation monetary administration programs.”
Stablecoins are backed by reserves together with conventional foreign money, commodities and Treasury securities. That’s supposed to make sure that their worth — not like that of, say, Bitcoin — doesn’t fluctuate. Nonetheless, on several high-profile occasions, the worth of stablecoins has achieved simply that.
On the HUD assembly, attendees mentioned a “proof of idea” mission during which CPD would start to trace the funding going to a single CPD grant recipient and presumably subrecipients on the blockchain. The necessity for the mission was “not effectively articulated,” one attendee later wrote in assembly notes.
Following the assembly, a HUD official wrote and circulated a memo inside the company panning the thought. “With out exaggeration, each conceivable implementation of this at HUD seems harmful and inefficient,” the memo reads.
HUD has no problem monitoring grant spending, the memo contended, making the brand new know-how pointless. Incorporating it might be time-consuming, difficult and require intensive coaching. And, if the mission concerned paying grantees in cryptocurrency as a substitute of {dollars}, it might inject volatility and unpredictability into the funding stream, even when the foreign money was a stablecoin.
In subsequent discussions with HUD staffers, the memo’s creator described the proposal as a “beachhead” at HUD for the introduction of cryptocurrency, which the creator in comparison with “monopoly cash.”
CPD officers continued to boost issues in a follow-up assembly, a recording of which was reviewed by ProPublica. (Judson didn’t attend this one.) Some attendees noticed advantage within the blockchain concept, suggesting it might cut back inaccurate information from grant recipients and allow real-time reporting and monitoring of their spending.
“Perhaps there’s something that we might study from it,” one stated, “particularly if we really feel just like the broader federal authorities is transferring in direction of some form of stablecoin possibility sooner or later.”
One official requested why the company was contemplating the mission. “As a result of it’s attractive,” somebody replied. One other stated, “Irv has requested us to pursue blockchain, in order that’s why we’re it,” referring to Dennis.
Many particulars have been left unexplained on the assembly, together with, crucially, whether or not the proposal would contain paying grantees in cryptocurrency. However some signaled that it might.
“You are able to do it with what can be connected to a steady foreign money. That will be as much as Treasury, and I believe they’re already going that method, for what it’s price,” one official stated. “It might simulate the greenback.”
One other added, “It might mainly be a cryptocurrency that’s linked to the U.S. greenback on a one-for-one foundation.”
A finance official prompt the thought could possibly be utilized extra broadly throughout HUD. “We’re this for your entire enterprise. We simply needed to start out in CPD,” he stated. The company can also be contemplating the thought for the Workplace of Public and Indian Housing, he stated, for “tenant eligibility and stuff like that.” That workplace serves the hundreds of thousands of people that stay in public and federally sponsored housing.
This isn’t the primary time that federal officers have thought-about incorporating the blockchain into the work of the federal government. Businesses together with the Treasury Division, the Division of Commerce and even HUD have been concerned in a research, a prototype and a working group lately. However those that monitor the crypto trade weren’t conscious of as broad an software of the know-how within the federal authorities as what HUD officers have lately mentioned.
Some crypto consultants have been doubtful. “It’s a horrible concept,” stated Corey Frayer, a former official on the U.S. Securities and Trade Fee, the place he targeted on the crypto markets and monetary stability. “It’s completely wild that anybody with any sense would contemplate this.”
Frayer, now on the Client Federation of America, warned that HUD grants paid in stablecoin might fall in worth. He expressed best concern in regards to the notion that the proposal might develop to different elements of the company. If that included, for instance, introducing stablecoin into the $1.3 trillion in mortgage insurance coverage supplied by the Federal Housing Administration, a fluctuation within the worth of the stablecoin might have a serious financial influence, he stated.
“Think about a world during which the entire authorities involvement within the housing trade, the entire funds circulating in that surroundings, dropped in worth by 13%,” he stated, citing a 2023 episode during which a stablecoin briefly fell 13 cents below the greenback. “It’s exhausting to think about that wouldn’t be catastrophic.”
Hilary Allen, a regulation professor at American College who researches monetary regulation and know-how, famous that some high-profile makes an attempt to make use of the blockchain for functions unrelated to cryptocurrency have failed. She expressed skepticism that the know-how would fare higher within the context of presidency grants, the place dangerous outcomes might hurt those that rely upon HUD funding to outlive.
“Blockchain know-how has been round for 15 years. Nobody desires to make use of it. And so now we now have an try and power the federal government to make use of it,” she stated, with “essentially the most weak folks” serving “as guinea pigs.”
Mollie Simon contributed analysis.
