By Charlie Garcia
Why bitcoin is in a bear market and why it might go decrease. And why I am nonetheless shopping for it for my grandkids.
Bitcoin, after all, by no means had a proper IPO, however the identical economics apply.
We’re in all probability eight to 10 months into the bitcoin ‘whales’ selling course of. In inventory markets, these overhangs normally run six to 18 months.
For those who personal bitcoin (BTCUSD) proper now, you in all probability really feel like the sober man at a frat celebration. The S&P 500 SPX has been flirting with all-time highs. The Nasdaq COMP has been on a tear. Gold (GC00) has topped $4,000 an ounce. Synthetic-intelligence shares are priced as if AI has already changed half of us.
And bitcoin? Down greater than 20% from its peak. Caught in a spread. The monetary equal of watching paint dry on a jail wall.
So what went mistaken? Did the Nice Digital Future get canceled?
No. One thing a lot much less dramatic and much more acquainted is going on: Bitcoin goes by the identical factor Amazon.com, Google and others skilled after they went public. It’s having an IPO second.
It’s simply altering palms from the individuals who bought wealthy to the individuals who need to.
Do not miss: Bitcoin simply worn out all of its 2025 features. What a crypto winter might appear to be.
When bitcoin stopped dancing with the Nasdaq
For years, bitcoin behaved like a tech inventory that had downed a triple espresso. When the Nasdaq went up, bitcoin went up extra. When massive tech bought off, bitcoin fell off a cliff.
That sample broke in late 2024. Since then, the Nasdaq has climbed, the S&P 500 is close to its highs, gold has gone parabolic – traditional threat-on habits.
And bitcoin? It isn’t collapsing. It simply refuses to affix the celebration.
When an asset is robust sufficient to not crash however too heavy to rally with the whole lot else, that is normally not a macro drawback. It is a shareholder drawback. In shares, that is what you see after an IPO when insiders are lastly allowed to promote.
The ‘silent IPO’: Bitcoin’s early holders are lastly cashing out. Loosen up.
An organization goes public. Large first day. Really feel-good headlines. However the early traders cannot promote instantly. They’re locked up for months. When that lockup ends, they do not dump all of it on a Tuesday. They distribute slowly into power.
As an example, Amazon (AMZN) IPO’d in 1997 at $18, hit $100 inside three years, then consolidated for 2 years regardless of the web exploding. Shares of Alphabet (GOOGL) (GOOG), then Google, went sideways for nearly two years after the 2004 IPO. Meta Platforms (META), then Fb, after its IPO in 2012? Similar sample when the lockups expired.
Here’s what issues: that these shareholders promote as a result of they lastly can – not as a result of they assume the enterprise is doomed. The inventory trades sideways whereas that overhang clears, whilst the firm retains rising.
Bitcoin, after all, by no means had a proper IPO, however the identical economics apply. The “founders and VCs” listed here are the miners and early consumers who picked up bitcoin at $10, $100, $1,000 – and held on whereas the remainder of us referred to as them lunatics.
Now we’ve got SEC-permitted bitcoin trade-traded funds, Wall Road desks, institutional custody, even sovereign funds lurking. For the first time in bitcoin’s historical past, you may quietly transfer billions with out knocking the value off the desk.
And that is precisely what’s occurring. For instance, Galaxy Digital not too long ago disclosed transferring $9 billion in bitcoin for a single shopper, one in all the authentic holders methodically exiting. Blockchain knowledge from Glassnode present cash which were dormant since 2010-13 transferring for the first time – not in panic however in “persistent, staggered distribution.”
What we’re seeing now is sort of a silent IPO: early, outsized holders distributing to a much wider base of consumers who got here in by ETFs, brokerages and company treasuries.
Do not imagine me? Take a look at Circle (CRCL) and CoreWeave (CRWV) – each IPO’d in 2025, each popped early, each consolidating now regardless of sturdy markets. Similar sample. Totally different asset class.
Learn: Crypto ‘whales’ are selling bitcoin because it sinks additional beneath $100,000. Ought to traders be nervous?
Scared cash vs. wealthy individuals taking chips off the desk
In 2022, individuals bought crypto as a result of they had been scared and broke. In 2025, individuals are selling as a result of they’re wealthy.
When you’ve got a imprecise PTSD flashback to bitcoin’s “crypto winter,” let’s be clear. In 2022, individuals bought crypto as a result of they had been scared and broke. In 2025, individuals are selling as a result of they’re wealthy. These are usually not the identical factor.
In 2022, main exchanges failed, frauds had been uncovered and other people bought as a result of they thought bitcoin may go to zero. There was no deep institutional bid. The worth collapsed 70% and extra as a result of religion and liquidity evaporated.
This time, bitcoin ETFs are reside and functioning. Advisers, pensions and household workplaces can push a button and purchase. Community fundamentals are close to all-time highs. The sellers are winners taking income at costs of $90,000-plus, not losers puking at the backside.
When do the crypto ‘whales’ cease selling?
In inventory markets, these overhangs normally run six to 18 months after lockups finish. Bitcoin’s “lockup” successfully ended when it broke above $100,000 and ETFs proved they might take up enormous blocks with out chaos. That was late final yr. For those who purchase the analogy, we’re in all probability eight to 10 months into the course of.
May bitcoin go decrease? After all. But when your time horizon is 20 years, the distinction between shopping for at $100,000 and shopping for at $80,000 issues extra to your cocktail-celebration tales than to your grandchildren’s web value.
Bitcoin isn’t a commerce. It is a time machine.
Bitcoin will not be one thing you scalp between Fed conferences.
For those who’re attempting to commerce this, you are in the mistaken sport. Bitcoin will not be one thing you scalp between Fed conferences. It’s one thing you purchase in a dimension you may reside with and plan to carry for 10 to twenty years.
You purchase it as one software in a portfolio the place each asset does a distinct job. Revenue-producing property pay you whilst you sleep. Equities with quickly rising dividends outrun inflation. Money is your optionality. Warren Buffett sits on a mountain of it in order that, when this costly market lastly journeys, he has dry powder.
Bitcoin is none of these.
In my portfolio, bitcoin is the moonshot sleeve. It does not pay revenue. It does not exchange money. It does not ship you a dividend verify.
What it does is provide you with publicity to the risk that, 20 years from now, nonsovereign digital cash is as regular as smartphones and that the authentic, hardest-to-kill model nonetheless instructions a premium.
10% of your portfolio remains to be the quantity. Here’s learn how to use it.
I’ve argued that as much as 10% of your investable property in bitcoin is cheap in case you perceive what you are shopping for and might tolerate massive drawdowns. I have not modified that view as a result of bitcoin is sluggish and social media has gotten gloomy.
Here’s how I translate that into motion: For those who imagine the lengthy-time period story and your allocation is nicely beneath your ceiling, greenback-value averaging on this vary is defensible. You are shopping for whereas the outdated guard palms you the keys.
For those who’re at zero, do not dash to 10% tomorrow. Begin with a toehold. Reside with it for a number of quarters. This isn’t “all in or bust.” That is portfolio building.
I am shopping for extra. Here’s why.
Bitcoin is a horrible day commerce and an wonderful 20-yr maintain for a particular slice of your web value.
For the report, sure, I purchased extra bitcoin. Not as a result of I do know the place the backside is – I do not – however as a result of my time horizon is 20 years, not 20 days.
I’ve put small quantities of bitcoin into accounts for my three grandchildren, ages 6 months, 2 and 4. If bitcoin is value a fraction of what I feel it could possibly be 20 years from now, they will have a significant head begin, a little bit slice of generational wealth created by an asset that their grandpa refused to commerce like a meme inventory. If I am mistaken, their lives will not be ruined. It is a sleeve, not the complete portfolio.
Bitcoin is a horrible day commerce and an wonderful 20-yr maintain for a particular slice of your web value. It could drift decrease as the early adopters end their silent IPO. It could frustrate you earlier than it rewards you. However in case you imagine bitcoin survives and matures, your job is to not guess the subsequent $10,000 transfer.
Your job is to resolve what position it performs, how a lot you may afford to place there and whether or not you are keen to carry it lengthy sufficient in your grandchildren to resolve whether or not you had been a genius or an fool.
My guess is that they’ll thank me.
Charlie Garcia is founder and a managing associate of R360, a peer-to-peer group for people and households with a web value of $100 million or extra. He holds positions in bitcoin and gold.
Agree? Disagree? Share your feedback with Charlie Garcia at charlie@R360Global.com. Your letter could also be printed anonymously in the weekly “Expensive Charlie” reader mailbag. By emailing your feedback to Charlie Garcia, you comply with have them printed on MarketWatch anonymously, or together with your first identify in case you give permission.
You perceive and agree that Dow Jones & Co., the writer of MarketWatch, might use your story, or variations of it, in all media and platforms, together with by way of third events.
Extra from Charlie Garcia:
How $5,000 grew to become $31 billion: 5 market classes from the biggest dealer ever
The robots have gained. The sensible commerce now’s investing in firms that make them.
Assume your bond funds and ETFs are protected investments? The credit score market is mendacity to you.
-Charlie Garcia
This content material was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is printed independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Road Journal.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
11-18-25 0816ET
Copyright (c) 2025 Dow Jones & Firm, Inc.
