State Tax Competitiveness
by Tom Yamachika, President, Tax Basis Hawaii
For a number of years now, the national Tax Foundation has put out a analysis report rating the 50 states and the District of Columbia on “tax competitiveness,” which it beforehand referred to as a examine on states’ enterprise tax local weather. It charges not solely how closely a state taxes its citizenry, but additionally the complexity of the tax system, its neutrality, and a number of other different values. This index additionally appears to have credibility right here in Hawaii, as our very personal DBEDT has been monitoring the index within the State of Hawaii Knowledge E book.

On this 12 months’s Index, the first driver of Hawaii’s low scores are the online earnings tax and state unemployment insurance coverage (SUI) tax.
Our Basic Excise Tax (GET) shouldn’t be the largest drawback as a result of, though the tax pyramids and business-to-business transactions can nonetheless appeal to a number of tax, the nominal price, at 4.5% together with county surcharge, shouldn’t be very excessive amongst states which have a gross sales tax.
Our web earnings tax may be very advanced, with twelve tax brackets together with the millionaire’s bracket enacted on this previous legislative session. It additionally comes with a ton of various credit obtainable to decrease earnings taxpayers, a lot of whom in all probability don’t perceive the entire credit and make the most of them. The chart reveals an uptick, to forty second, in 2025, however the Tax Basis has warned us in this year’s study that as a result of the rankings are based mostly on the regulation in impact the earlier 12 months (2024), the rankings are based mostly on the 2024 tax cuts. As a result of these cuts had been at the least partially reversed in 2025, they stated, our 2026 report rankings are more likely to drop. (And apart from, being forty second is nothing to brag about.)
The second driver of our low rankings is SUI, the place our state sometimes scrapes the underside of the rankings and we’re forty ninth this 12 months. It is because we’ve got a fairly excessive SUI price and an infinite (in contrast with different states) most quantity of wages that’s taxed (referred to as the taxable wage base). Most state SUI techniques tax solely the primary few thousand {dollars} of wage, as the subsequent chart reveals. Solely the state of Washington has a taxable wage base above $70,000, and our state is the one one within the $60,000-$70,000 vary.

Supply: Compiled by Microsoft Copilot from public sources.
If we wish to have a look at tax reform making us extra aggressive among the many states, then, the online earnings tax and the SUI levy are the locations to begin.










