Issue 88 – The stockchain

Related articles

Binance allegedly wrote the code for WLFI’s stablecoin USD1

July 12, 2025

Binance Aids Trump-Tied Firm in USD1 Stablecoin Launch, $2 Billion Deal

July 11, 2025

Take heed to me learn this publish right here (not an AI-generated voice!), subscribe to the feed in your podcast app, or download the recording for later.

The crypto world has two current buzzwords: “tokenization” and “real-world property” (RWAs). Gone are the times when crypto evangelists dreamed of tearing down conventional monetary establishments altogether. Now, crypto corporations appear intent on replicating the monetary system, minus laws that may safeguard shoppers or financial stability. Subsequent of their sights? Inventory exchanges.

Distinguished crypto corporations resembling Robinhood, Republic, Coinbase, and Kraken are quickly transferring in direction of “tokenizing” conventional shares, and pressuring regulators to permit it. As an alternative of shopping for your shares of publicly traded corporations through a brokerage account that locations orders on the NYSE or Nasdaq, you’ll use a crypto buying and selling app to buy a token representing a share. Firms hoping to develop such platforms normally promote the thought by saying {that a} blockchainified inventory market would increase buying and selling hours, and could be extra accessible to worldwide traders who didn’t need to undergo the considerably onerous means of opening an American brokerage account.

These corporations don’t normally admit that, by encasing shares in a blockchainy wrapper, they hope to faucet into profitable equities markets whereas sidestepping the costly compliance and oversight necessities of conventional American brokerages and exchanges. This suits the lengthy historical past of corporations attempting to make use of blockchains as a magic get-out-of-regulation-free wand, paying homage to the 2017 bubble when corporations used “initial coin offerings” (ICOs) to attempt to sidestep IPO laws. Certainly, Robinhood has been closely lobbying for “a brand new regulatory method [that’s] wanted to permit tokenization to flourish” and never “stifle progress and innovation”.¹ Common readers of this text will acknowledge this language as the usual rhetoric of a crypto firm asking for carveouts and exemptions from laws we collectively realized are mandatory, oh, about a century ago — when a speculative bubble emerged round shares bought to the general public based mostly on false or incomplete info and we wound up within the Nice Despair.

Some corporations have gone even additional, tokenizing shares in non-public corporations. When Robinhood introduced its tokenized equities providing (solely out there to European traders in the mean time whereas the corporate works on lobbying US lawmakers and regulators), in addition they introduced that that they had tokenized shares within the non-public corporations SpaceX and OpenAI. This prompted considerations from European regulators and OpenAI themselves, who tweeted: “These ‘OpenAI tokens’ will not be OpenAI fairness. We didn’t associate with Robinhood, weren’t concerned on this, and don’t endorse it. Any switch of OpenAI fairness requires our approval—we didn’t approve any switch. Please watch out.”²³

Cash Stuff’s Matt Levine put it properly in his must-read newsletter on the subject when he wrote:

The “authorized friction” [Robinhood mentions] is that some corporations are non-public as a result of they don’t need to adjust to securities disclosure guidelines, and tokenization’s resolution is that they will promote inventory to the general public with out complying with these guidelines. … Saying “we must always do away with the disclosure guidelines” sounds unhealthy, retrograde, grasping. Saying “tokenization” sounds good, trendy, cool.

Crypto corporations already barreling ahead with blockchainified shares have hit some resistance from somebody they could not have anticipated: SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce, who has in any other case been such a staunch ally of the crypto trade that she earned (and embraced) the moniker “Crypto Mother”. On July 9, she cautioned, “As highly effective as blockchain know-how is, it doesn’t have magical talents to remodel the character of the underlying asset. Tokenized securities are nonetheless securities.”⁴ Whereas that is quickly reassuring, payments just like the CLARITY Act, presently making their method by Congress, threaten to undermine the SEC on this space. In a July 9 Senate Banking Committee listening to, former CFTC Chairman Timothy Massad agreed with Rating Member Elizabeth Warren that the invoice “might undermine [the SEC’s] authority considerably”, successfully turning blockchains into the regulatory escape hatch the trade wishes.⁵

(*88*)

Due to everybody who’s crammed out the Quotation Wanted reader survey! Should you haven’t but, I’d love your enter — it helps me maintain writing a publication value your time.

Take the survey

In authorities

Crypto was an afterthought in Congress these previous couple weeks as lawmakers battled it out over the finances reconciliation invoice, nevertheless it’s again with a vengeance as Home Republicans have formally declared subsequent week to be “Crypto Week”.⁶ The Home is pushing for a vote on the GENIUS Act stablecoin invoice, which already handed within the Senate, they usually’ve stopped attempting to advance their very own STABLE Act after urging from Trump [I86]. The home will even be contemplating the CLARITY Act market construction invoice [I85], and a invoice referred to as the Anti-CBDC Surveillance State Act.

CLARITY Act

The CLARITY Act could face extra resistance than GENIUS, with Rating Member Warren decrying it as “one other trade handout that offers the crypto foyer precisely its want record”. Former CFTC Chairman Massad dubbed it “236 pages of regulatory arbitrage alternatives for artistic legal professionals”.⁷ Legislation professor Richard Painter warned: “The danger is that we repeat the expertise of regulating the banks within the Twenties and the Despair that adopted. 10 years of melancholy. The danger is that we repeat what occurred in 2008, when marketing campaign contributions poured into Congress from the securities-based swap trade, elsewhere within the monetary companies trade, and we had many years of deregulation. The economic system collapsed. Thousands and thousands of American households dropping their properties, individuals unemployed. We’ve been by this repeatedly.”⁸

Republican Senators spent appreciable time through the listening to chastising witnesses and fellow legislators alike for daring to say the crypto foyer’s affect. Senator Kennedy (R-LA) spent about half of his allotted time demanding that Professor Painter apologize to Senator Gillibrand (D-NY), claiming he referred to as her a “criminal” on Twitter again in Might.

Kennedy was form sufficient to learn the tweet aloud, serving to each make clear that Painter by no means described her as such, and be sure that the official report now displays Painter’s completely correct tweet:

If Kennedy thinks accepting crypto cash makes one a criminal, properly, maybe he ought to do one thing about that. (Kennedy himself accepted virtually $40,000 in 2024, all from Cumberland DRW’s Donald Wilson. This comparatively low quantity in comparison with different crypto-backed Congresspeople is probably going as a result of Kennedy was not up for re-election in 2024.)

Evidently angered by Painter’s refusal to take the bait and his requests that they really talk about the proposed invoice as a substitute of losing time mischaracterizing tweets, Kennedy lashed out: “You’re a whackjob. You’re a main league, next-level whackjob.” On the finish of the listening to, Chairman Tim Scott proclaimed, “I hope all of us bear in mind very clearly that our phrases are containers of energy”, happening to not rebuke the Senator for attacking a witness as a “main league, next-level whackjob” however as a substitute those that “weaponize[d words] towards Senator Gillibrand or President Trump”. (Notably, Painter didn’t deliver up Gillibrand; it was Kennedy who printed out Painter’s tweet to learn on the listening to.)

Anti-CBDC invoice

The slightly alarmist-named Anti-CBDC Surveillance State Act exemplifies the peculiar Republican stance on digital forex surveillance. They’ve someway satisfied themselves that Federal Reserve banks are poised to launch a CBDC (central financial institution digital forex) that might allow mass surveillance — although no such plan has been significantly proposed. By some means, stopping this imaginary menace takes precedence over addressing issues just like the president’s personal stablecoin, which has already given him the forms of surveillance and management powers they concern in CBDCs. Certainly, these considerations have principally come from the Democratic wing of Congress, and have been disregarded by Republicans who’re largely terrified to criticize something Trump does.

And whereas Republicans decry purely hypothetical CBDC surveillance, they celebrated crypto’s precise surveillance capabilities on the current Senate listening to, the place Senators and crypto executives alike delighted in how blockchains’ public ledgers ease tracing by legislation enforcement and, frankly, anybody else. Conveniently, recording all transactions publicly means legislation enforcement not must receive a pesky subpoena to peek in in your monetary actions!

Senator Tim Scott (R-SC): [C]rypto corporations are serving to legislation enforcement monitor illicit exercise with larger precision than conventional finance permits. … Blockchain know-how creates a everlasting traceable ledger that may assist legislation enforcement catch these unhealthy actors. I’ve stated it earlier than, so I will say it once more: It is simpler to trace one thing that has a digital footprint than one thing that doesn’t.

Senator Katie Britt (R-AL): And transactions on the blockchain supply a novel potential for tracing and monitoring, together with analyzing developments on the ledger.

Brad Garlinghouse, Ripple CEO: I feel the excellent news has been in lots of instances [bad actors] do not typically perceive how traceable and trackable [using digital assets] really is and it is extra trackable than, clearly, money.

Again in 2023, I wrote a tweet thread about how “the previous ~month or so i’ve all of a sudden began seeing a bunch of individuals in crypto and within the monetary regulatory/enforcement world who’re unironically enthusiastic about crypto due to the monetary surveillance it might empower, and that scares the shit out of me.” I discussed listening to a panel about how “algorithms” might detect legal exercise on public ledgers in actual time to routinely alert legislation enforcement, and even be programmed into the cash itself to cease transactions. The dystopian future I anxious about then is now being celebrated in Congress as a function.

Within the White Home

Analysis by Residents for Duty and Ethics in Washington (CREW) reveals that 19 White Home officers personal between $875,000 and $2.35 million in crypto property resembling bitcoin and Ethereum, standing to immediately revenue from President Trump’s March government order directing the institution of nationwide crypto reserves [Crypto reserves]. One in every of them, Particular Assistant to the President for Communications Ian Kelley, holds all 5 of the property Trump talked about by identify in social media posts as probably candidates for the stockpile.⁹

Trump enterprise pursuits

Bear in mind Aqua 1 Basis, the agency I discussed final concern had purchased $100 million of the Trump memecoin [I87]? A brand new report by Jacob Silverman in The Nation questions: “Does Trump’s Biggest Crypto Backer Really Exist?” “It’s unclear the place the actual cash powering this deal originated,” he writes. “It’s doable that Aqua 1 Basis is an actual Emirati firm, nevertheless it’s simply as doable that it may very well be a entrance for any variety of overseas monetary or political pursuits searching for favors from Trump.”¹⁰

In the meantime, shady crypto billionaire Justin Solar apparently doesn’t need to be outdone by Aqua 1, and has pledged to spend one other $100 million, this time on the Trump memecoin, to safe the spot of Trump’s primary benefactor bestie.¹¹ Including to his $75 million of WLFI tokens, and the round $38 million he or his firm already spent on the Trump memecoin, this may put the entire quantity of Solar’s Trump-related token purchases at roughly $213 million.

Most Trump memecoin patrons will not be shopping for immediately from Trump-affiliated entities, however on the secondary market, that means that whereas Trump entities could earn some revenue from buying and selling charges, they’re not profiting immediately from the token sale. Nonetheless, the timing of Solar’s announcement — a bit over per week earlier than the primary tranche of memecoins held by Trump-affiliated entities are resulting from unlock on the market — signifies that it’s doable Solar plans to buy the tokens immediately from a kind of entities. Up to now, not less than $56 million of Solar’s cash has gone on to Trump himself (through his belief) or Trump relations; that quantity might almost triple if they’re those promoting him the tokens.

As I wrote in November, shortly after Trump’s World Liberty Monetary opened its WLFI token sale:

[The token has] strict limitations round token resale and remuneration to token holders, and availability solely to accredited traders — limitations which have been slightly clearly crafted to attempt to dodge securities enforcement. If Trump succeeds along with his plans to defang the SEC, I count on these limitations to swiftly change — probably considerably financially benefiting Trump and his household, who obtain 75% of internet protocol revenues along with their preliminary allocation of twenty-two.5 billion $WLFI tokens.

Effectively, wouldn’t it, the workforce behind World Liberty has simply proposed lifting the restrictions to permit WLFI to be resold.¹² As with many different crypto companies currently, they haven’t even bothered to attend for crypto laws to cross in Congress, and are as a substitute counting on the paralyzed SEC to not implement current legislation.

Though World Liberty has but to truly launch any of the software program they declare they’ve been creating since September, they are saying that permitting secondary gross sales of the token will “deliver us one step nearer to constructing a extra open, clear, and highly effective monetary system”. It appears to me like really constructing some software program is perhaps a much bigger step, however hey, I suppose cashing in on the token takes precedence. This proposal, which has to this point acquired overwhelming assist, may very well be very profitable for individuals like Solar and, after all, the Trumps.

Trump Media & Expertise Group, the bulk Trump-owned firm behind Reality Social, has filed to record a “Reality Social Crypto Blue Chip ETF” monitoring a portfolio of bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, Ripple’s XRP, and Crypto.com’s CRO.¹³ The first 4 tokens make sense for a fund claiming to characterize “blue chip” cryptocurrencies, as these are a few of the most extremely traded cryptocurrencies. The odd one out is CRO, which is probably going solely included as a result of Reality Social is partnering with Singaporean crypto trade Crypto.com for custody companies. Whereas many purposes have been filed, no ETFs have but been authorised involving crypto property in addition to bitcoin or Ethereum.

Reality Social additionally introduced that will probably be rolling out “gems” on Reality Social, which it guarantees will “ultimately” be linked to a “utility token”.¹⁴ That is a part of a brand new $9.99/mo subscription TV streaming plan it’s calling the Patriot Bundle, which provides one other 12 “premium, non-woke information channels” (like Newsmax and OANN) to the record of 27 (like Real America’s Voice and Lindell TV) within the Reality+ free plan.

In regulators

Crypto corporations Circle, Ripple, and BitGo have utilized for Nationwide Belief Financial institution charters, which, if authorised, would insert them immediately into the guts of the normal monetary system.¹⁵ “Stoking the system with banks closely linked to enterprise capital and crypto may very well be a horrible thought, nonetheless,” wrote Bloomberg columnist Paul J. Davies in what may very well be the understatement of the 12 months. Not less than these charters don’t routinely grant banks entry to grasp accounts (though it allows them to request entry), nor do they permit them to take demand deposits or have interaction in lending.¹⁶

These charters, granted by the Workplace of the Comptroller of the Forex, have traditionally been arduous for crypto corporations to acquire, so that they have as a substitute resorted to attempting to worm their method into the banking world in bizarre methods like by buying tiny rural banks. However shortly after these corporations utilized for charters, the Senate confirmed former blockchain government Jonathan Gould as Comptroller of the Forex.¹⁷ Along with approving banking charters, the OCC will oversee stablecoin issuers beneath the proposed GENIUS Act: probably motivating these purposes by stablecoin issuers Circle and Ripple and “stablecoin-as-a-service” firm BitGo, which custodies the reserves for Trump’s USD1 stablecoin.

One other financial institution referred to as Erebor, which as you may guess by the Lord of the Rings identify is backed by Peter Thiel, Joe Lonsdale, and Palmer Luckey, has additionally utilized for a financial institution constitution. In keeping with the Monetary Instances, the brand new financial institution will purpose to “fill the hole left by Silicon Valley Bank” — the tech startup-focused financial institution that failed in March 2023.¹⁸ Round 85% of Silicon Valley Financial institution’s deposits, principally belonging to enterprise capitalists and venture-backed tech corporations, have been uninsured; the FDIC nonetheless coated these uninsured depositors and spent $20 billion on the entire boondoggle.¹⁹ As is so typically the case with “tech visionaries”, yesterday’s warning lesson is tomorrow’s blueprint.

SEC

The complete tokenized inventory factor is incomes a combined reception from conventional monetary corporations and from regulators. Whereas SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce wrote that “Tokenized securities are nonetheless securities”, SEC Chairman Atkins stated in a CNBC interview that “tokenization is an innovation, and we on the SEC must be centered on how will we advance innovation within the market”.²⁰

The Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (SIFMA), a serious commerce group for securities corporations, banks, and asset administration corporations, despatched a letter to the SEC concerning experiences that crypto corporations have been searching for no-action letters or exemptive aid from the SEC for tokenized equities, urging them to reject the requests and as a substitute have interaction in public coverage discussions. These requests, if granted by the SEC, would permit corporations to have interaction in actions which can be both in an unsure regulatory state or prohibited by securities legal guidelines. SIFMA raised considerations over “basic questions as to how traders could be protected”, and opined that “Permitting sure entities to function platforms outdoors of this framework raises vital coverage questions and regulatory arbitrage considerations”.²¹ Some within the crypto trade bashed SIFMA for the letter, with Paradigm VP of Authorities Affairs Alexander Grieve tweeting: “TL;DR: they hate [tokenized stocks] & need to shield their market place. … The previous gods of finance don’t share energy calmly.”²²

In elections and political affect

Reeling from a dramatic breakup with President Trump and livid on the finances reconciliation invoice, Elon Musk declared he would begin a brand new political occasion referred to as the America Get together. As Lyz from Males Yell at Me writes, “The man who gave us the primary AI chatbot to go full Hitler and a truck so ugly your grandma has been protesting it from her nursing residence has determined to invent one thing else: a brand new political occasion.”²³

Musk claims it’s going to characterize “the 80 % within the center” of the political spectrum, although this appears unlikely given statements suggesting that the occasion’s platform will mirror his private political beliefs, that are decidedly not centrist. Requested on Twitter, “Will America Get together embrace Bitcoin?”, Musk replied: “Fiat is hopeless, so sure”. Whether or not this new pro-bitcoin occasion will really emerge, or Musk shall be distracted by the subsequent shiny factor to cross inside his visual field, stays to be seen.

Within the courts

A Nigerian scammer impersonating Steve Witkoff and the Trump-Vance Inaugural Committee tricked a donor into sending him $250,000 [W3IGG]. The precise Witkoff, a longtime Trump ally now put in because the US particular envoy to the Center East regardless of having no diplomatic expertise, was on the time co-chair of the Presidential Inaugural Committee. He and his sons are additionally deeply concerned in Trump’s World Liberty Monetary crypto enterprise. Utilizing the traditional “lowercase Ls appear to be uppercase Is” trick, a scammer obtained the e-mail tackle steve_witkoff@t47lnaugural.com and used it to solicit 1 / 4 million {dollars} from “Ivan & Mouna” in an electronic mail despatched on December 24. As Claire Heddles at NOTUS noticed, these simply so occur to be the primary names of the MoonPay crypto platform’s CEO and CFO, and the switch got here from a crypto pockets belonging to MoonPay.²⁴ MoonPay had advised Fox Enterprise days earlier than the switch that they deliberate to contribute an undisclosed quantity to the inaugural fund.²⁵ In a certainly coincidental improvement, MoonPay could be chosen solely weeks later by Trump’s memecoin endeavor to deal with cost processing. MoonPay boasted that that they had “onboarded 750,000 new shoppers” because of the partnership.

The FBI recovered $40,353, about 16% of the stolen funds, by seizure requests to Tether and Binance.²⁶ Mark Hays, a cryptocurrency reform advocate with People for Monetary Reform and Demand Progress, advised NOTUS that if MoonPay was certainly the sufferer on this incident, “that smacks of favoritism or selective enforcement. … Should you’re pleasant with Trump and also you’re a Trump crypto bro, you get the DOJ proactively attempting to get better your property, even when there will not be too many zeroes on a rounding sheet. However when you’re a median shopper and also you lose your life financial savings due to a memecoin fronted by those self same individuals, nobody’s going that can assist you.”²⁴

The metropolis of Detroit has sued RealT, a “tokenized actual property” agency that bought lots of of rental properties throughout town and bought fractionalized shares to overseas traders. They’ve additionally brought about hell for renters and town — failing to take care of the deteriorating and unsafe properties; refusing to pay payments, taxes, or tickets; and attempting to dodge the legislation utilizing 165 company entities.²⁷

In bankruptcies

The FTX property has requested to pause repayments to collectors based mostly in 49 nations whereas they consider whether or not it’s authorized to distribute funds to them. Among the nations on the record, resembling North Korea, Iran, and Cuba, are topic to US sanctions; others have legal guidelines limiting crypto transactions. In keeping with FTX, residents of the doubtless restricted nations maintain round 5% of the worth of all doubtlessly allowed claims, with 82% of the doubtless restricted claims belonging to Chinese language collectors. FTX has proposed retaining attorneys to judge the feasibility of repaying residents of every jurisdiction. If it’s not possible, after an objection interval, FTX could forfeit payouts to residents of that jurisdiction.²⁸

A lawsuit by the bankrupt Celsius platform towards offshore stablecoin issuer Tether has survived a movement to dismiss. Celsius alleges that Tether bought off 39,500 BTC held as collateral for a mortgage in a “fireplace sale” at lower-than-market costs to recoup the mortgage, violating their lending settlement.²⁹ Some headlines have described this as a $4 billion lawsuit, based mostly on the concept that quantity of bitcoin could be value round $4 billion at right this moment’s (considerably greater) costs. Nonetheless, even when Tether did violate the lending settlement that required them to offer Celsius with ten hours to give you further collateral to keep away from defaulting on the mortgage, it appears unlikely to me that Celsius would have been in a position to take action if given the chance. Celsius was on fireplace and spiraling in direction of chapter on the time, failing to repay different loans, and I’m undecided the place they’d have discovered stated collateral.

It’s an fascinating lawsuit for a separate purpose, although: Tether did not persuade the choose that the claims have been an “impermissible extraterritorial utility” of chapter legal guidelines to an organization based mostly outdoors of the US. A lawyer talking to DL Information described the ruling as “a pivotal second that would doubtlessly reshape the authorized panorama for cross-border cryptocurrency disputes”.³⁰

Exterior the US

The EU’s monetary oversight physique is reviewing Malta’s adherence to the EU’s Markets in Crypto Property (MiCA) laws, after the small island nation fast-tracked the authorization of a crypto agency regardless of “materials points [that] remained unresolved or pending remediation on the time of the authorization.” CoinDesk has theorized the unnamed agency is perhaps the Seychelles-based OKX crypto trade, which was granted pre-authorization by Malta shortly earlier than reaching a $500 million settlement in a US legal case [I78].³¹

Elsewhere in crypto

Unhappy information, people: one other deliberate crypto island bites the mud. This one is Satoshi Island, which I discussed briefly all the way in which again in Issue 6 after I was interviewed for an ABC (Australia) article about it. This one had its sights set on Vanuatu, an island northeast of Australia and west of Fiji. Naturally, Satoshi Island bought a bunch of their “Land Deed NFTs” earlier than really constructing any of the stacks of modular properties depicted in digital renderings, they usually by no means appeared to sort out the issue that the land they have been “promoting” to NFT holders couldn’t really be bought. In January 2022, the Vanuatu Monetary Companies Fee warned the challenge “may very well be a rip-off”. Now, the Satoshi Island Twitter account has introduced the termination of the settlement between Vanuatu and Satoshi Island, seemingly resulting from Satoshi Island’s failure to truly develop the challenge. Worry not, they’re “presently exploring a voluntary buyback”. Hopefully they’ll work on that a bit tougher than they did the island residences.

They’re not the one crypto challenge to close down just lately. Three years after stopping withdrawals [W3IGG] within the wake of the Three Arrows Capital blowup [W3IGG], crypto yield farming challenge Finblox is formally pulling the plug. They’d drawn in prospects with guarantees of “as much as 90% APY in your crypto!”, and even claimed that deposits have been insured as much as $45 million. It turned out they (together with what appeared like half of the crypto trade) have been issuing uncollateralized loans to the Three Arrows Capital hedge fund, which I’m certain was understanding nice for them whereas the quantity was going up solely. After the disaster, Finblox transformed buyer funds right into a Finblox-issued token referred to as FBX, which is now buying and selling at a value so near zero that crypto trackers resort to utilizing scientific notation.

Finblox founders preserve that they clearly defined the FBX conversion to prospects, who then opted in, however some prospects say they by no means agreed to it.³²

The Web3 is Going Simply Nice recap

There have been 5 entries between July 1 and 11, averaging 0.5 entries per day. $44.45 million was added to the grift counter.

• MoonPay apparently will get scammed out of a $250,000 donation to Trump inaugural fund [link]
• Kinto token crashes; group claims rug pull, Kinto claims hack [link]
• $2.2 million in consumer funds stolen from Texture; hacker returns 90% [link]
• Safety researchers disclose exploit that put over $10 million throughout a number of protocols in danger [link]
• GMX trade hacked for $42 million [link]

Within the information

Value a learn

Additionally, when you’re keen on my fiction studying suggestions, I revealed my June studying recap to TikTok and YouTube. I’ve been attempting to do considered one of these each month since March; they’re all on Tiktok and in a playlist on my YouTube channel when you’ve missed the earlier ones.

That is all for now, people. Till subsequent time,

– Molly White